Wine Spectator: 100 point wines. Can absolute perfection be reached when making wine? | Knowledge Base

Sponsor:

100 point wines. Can absolute perfection be reached when making wine?

I am reading a old issue of Wine Spectator, the front page article is about 100 point wines. I am skeptical. What about the mood and health of the taster. These are acknowledged factors in wine tasting

Responses:

it is probably possible by pure luck - working with the best ingredients. a vintner in San Fransisco told me once that their batch of wines had improved by the jolt of a recent earthquake. but rubbish in rubbish out. the same guy told me that in blind tasting he got a red and a white mixed - lol
Whether it is the 5 star system used by Decanter or the 100 point system used by Wine Spectator, Parker, Wines and Spirits, etc, both the consumer and the retailers use the scoring system to decide which wines to buy and sell. There are merits to the different scoring systems. I like Decanter's system which gives a score out of 20 as well as a rating out of five stars. This way, there is no "perfect" wine that scores 100 points just like I did on my Stats 151 exam all those years ago. However, it is frustrating when I am using Decanter to try and decide which Bordeaux to buy. If there are 50 wines that all have the same score and all have four stars, it is not helping me to choose how to spend my limited budget. The 100 point scale also has its pitfalls. How can one really accept that James ling's palate can without fail differentiate between a 98 point wine and a 96 point wine? Supposedly, the Wine Spectator tastings are conducted blind, but as you pointed out, there are intangible human factors in wine appreciation. Nevertheless, I find that ling's Bordeaux ratings do help me to choose what I buy. It helps to look at the Decanter, ling and Parker ratings together as well for consensus. As for a perfect wine, I do not think I have yet tasted one of the 100 point wines, though I do have a bottle of 2001 Rieussec that I am looking forward to trying in 20 years. it is interesting to read about great wines in the past that would have scored 100 points. It seems unanimous in tastings of, say, 1945 Mouton or 1961 Latour, that different tasters tasting at different times in different company, with different food will consistently call it an unforgettable experience, a wine that is unique and second to none. On the other hand, I believe Parker rated the 1990 Montrose 100 points but since then a number of other tasters consider this wine inferior to the 1989 and possibly has Brett taint. I do believe that there are some wines that simply have no flaws at all, and have achieved the perfect balance and harmony of alcohol, fruit, tannin and acidity. These are rare indeed, and reviewers need to be careful not to abuse their 100 point markers. Look for consistency amongst reviewers. Cheers! Sorry for being verbose
You're heading in the right direction. Wine tasting is all subjective. I am always very wary of ratings, especially when it comes to wine and food. There are too many variables and what might be perfection to one person may be swill to another. However, having said that, the people who rate wine are generally well - versed in the practice and even if you're not a fan of a particular grape, you can use their ratings to help guide you. But "perfection", I do not know. I have been battling that word myself as of late, especially when people throw it around so much

Tags: ratings, tasting, wine, decanter, point

Follow this dicussion..

Knowledge Base

California wine: Do you think it is evn better than French wine?

i like california wines better and they cost less too. yes. remember, ca beat france in a blind tasting back in 1978. i find ca wines more accessible and less pretentious. i think blossom hill wines are the best wines you can buy. i think it depends on taste. i

What is the best way to store wine if i do not plan to drink it for a month or two?

planning on drinking the wine in the next month or two. do i put it in the fridge. do i store it at room temp. or what?. depends on what kind of wine. white wine you could put it in the fridge but red wine you will want to store

Looking for an idea for an appetizer recipe for tailgating during a wine tour?

coming up with a sensational tailgate recipe has become quite the big deal on our annual wine tour. it has to be something that is easy to eat while standing, can be served quickly from the tailgate, looks good and tastes fabulous! thank you in advance. how about things that

Wine Gift?

it is my boyfriends 22nd birthday soon and i would really like to buy him a bottle of wine from 1986 for the novelty i suppose. does anyone know which internet site or where i could get an australian white chardonnay from 1986 that does not cost an arm and

can you make a country wine based on a meat?

i have recently started making country wines and was amazed at the vast amount of fruits, veggies, flowers, leaves and other stuff on which many recipes are based i have even read about a roman fish wine but couldnt find the recipe. i have not however found a recipe for

Knowledge Base: Wine

Learing about Wine?

i am interested in learning everything i can about wine, from the grapes that blend to make different varieties to how each wine tastes differently from another. i live in ny so i would not be able to take the wine spectator cl es, but i am looking for a

Would it be legal to donate homemade wine to a charity auction?

and if so, can you take a deduction for the estimated value, even though you could not legally sell it?. the legaility of the donation will vary by state in the us. check state laws. the charity might not want it, there might be legal issues for them as well.

What are your indulgeance for Christmas?

awesome!mine is pizza or wine coolers!i miss california wine coolers!. pecan pralines. since christmas is my birthday, i do not want turkey dinner. i have lobster for dinner. red velvet cake, with vanilla ice cream. almond bark pretzels rolled in crushed cinnamon candies

Has anyone been to wine country out in California? Any details about the best places to go?

my husband and i are planning a trip to wine country sonoma valley, napa valley and would love to hear any suggestions about cool wineries to go, etc. we do not care about having to go to all the "must see" places. we care more about having a good time

Is making wine good for dry ed feet?

was curious if stomping grapes helps to cure dry ed feet. i saw this was a method of wine making and had a vision of some nasty feet stomping the grapes. dean, i would never drink the wine if i found out that these feet had any part in the

When giving wine as a gift, how much should you spend?

i know you should definitely spend more than you would on a bottle for personal consumption - or i should, anyway. i usually spend less than usd 10 on a bottle if it just for me. how much should you spend if it is for a gift? monetary guidelines are

I am a wine lover, but is not easy find one for my taste, i prefer a california and not expensive

hello che34 i myself enjoy red wines i prefer a dryer red wine though like cabernet sauvignon, or a merlot or even a shiraz. you may want to get out of the california range and try. hello che34 i myself enjoy red wines i prefer a dryer red wine though

Knowledge Base: Wine Spectator

where do you get magazine wine spectator?

try this link: winespectator.com / wine / home / . if you want just one issue you can go to any store that sells magazines, most carry it. you can find really good deals on magazine subscriptions online too. i got my boyfriend wine spectator, and wine enthusiest for valentines

where do you get a magazine called "wine spectator"?

any good bookstore such as borders or barnes and noble. i have also seen it in better liquor / wine stores. high end liquor stores, such as the one next to shoprite in mays landing, nj. try searching the web. i once got a free subscription on the site dailyfreebies.com.

What is a good cabernet Sauvignon under USD 10?

if you want to just pick something out from a list, wine spectator has a daily list of recomendations, broken down by price range: winespectator.com / wine / daily_wine. a lot of great wine bargains are of limited availability and any given brand can vary in quality from year to

100 point wines. Can absolute perfection be reached when making wine?

i am reading a old issue of wine spectator, the front page article is about 100 point wines. i am skeptical. what about the mood and health of the taster. these are acknowledged factors in wine tasting. you're heading in the right direction. wine tasting is all subjective. i am

How do you keep the cork moist in a large format wine bottle?

a recent wine spectator magazine featured a number of spectacular wine cellars with collectible double magnums, jeroboams and other large format bottles proudly on display standing upright. how do these collectors keep the corks from drying out?. i would ume the display was for the pictures and perhaps portions of

Learing about Wine?

I enjoy wines. Is there any free site that does wine tasting scoring?

i know that the wine spectator is there but they charge a fee. i have done a number of searches and can not find any good sites for rating wines. i drink domestic and international wines. this one is put together by a very knowledgeable guy: you can view them